As a customer of Cay Insurance since their inception, we have been delighted with the value and service offered by this broker. It is most refreshing in this day and age of large companies where customers are just a number, to be able to deal with a company that provides a quick and personal response.

Mr. Armitage, VP Sellers of America, Dalton, Georgia

What began almost one hundred years ago as a local marine insurance brokerage has now evolved into Cay Insurance Services. We offer a full array of insurance products and services and have always stood for providing the very best in service with the industry’s highest quality and most reputable insurance companies.

Founded on the notion of putting our clients first, we stand for integrity, professionalism and helping our clients achieve the best insurance program possible. Please contact us and allow us to demonstrate our unique level of professional service.


I would personally like to let you know how pleased I am with the level of service your firm constantly delivers to me. Additionally, I want to communicate to you the magnificent impression Amanda Neidlinger has made to me. She is absolutely fantastic. You are very fortunate to have such a great person in your firm. She is outstandingly helpful, professional and delivers above and beyond service.

Mr. C. Caldwell, Savannah GA

Cay Insurance