Amanda Hinely

Mrs. Hinely joined Cay Insurance Services in 2008.  Prior to joining our firm, she worked for Palmer & Cay in the Personal Lines Department in Savannah.  She has over 14 years experience in the insurance industry.  In addition, she holds the ACSR certification (Accredited Customer Service Representative).  As an Account Manager, she provides exceptional service to her clients, providing a tailored approach to meet the needs of her clients.


Danette McGeeney

Ms. McGeeney became a part of Cay Insurance Services, Inc. in April 2014.  She has over 8 years of experience in the insurance industry.  Prior to becoming an insurance agent, she was a part of the hospitality industry.  Ms. McGeeney has an exceptional customer service background that allows her to be client focused an address the needs of each and every individual.


Jenny McNeal

Mrs. McNeal began working in the insurance business almost 18 years ago in her father’s agency in a small farm town in Ohio.  Following a move to the South in 2001, she has grown her knowledge and experience of the Insurance Industry to encompass all levels of significance, specializing in high net-worth clients.  She has worked for various brokers all of whose business was focused in the Southeast, and has been based in the Atlanta market for the last 3 years.  This experience has given her the ability to manage clients with varying needs, including coastal and rural exposures, while still maintaining a personalized, “small-town” approach.  She has earned her CISR (Certified Insurance Service Representative) designation and is constantly expanding her knowledge of the insurance market.  When not working, Jenny enjoys cooking, making jewelry and volunteering time to local animal charities.


Laurie Mills

Laurie Mills serves as Commercial Account Manager for Cay Insurance Services.  She has nearly 20 years experience in the insurance industry, specializing in property & casualty lines. Laurie has extensive experience in small business account management. Laurie began her insurance career in 1995 with Edwards Insurance Agency. She later worked for Palmer & Cay in the Private Accounts Division, managing and servicing accounts for high net-worth individuals. Prior to joining Cay Insurance Services, she worked for Wells Fargo Insurance Services/USI Insurance Services LLC as a Commercial Senior Account Manager for the small business unit. She resides in Savannah and in her spare time enjoys running and competing in 5K’s.



Cay Insurance